Scrape together some change and pick up a copy of Weird N.J magazine. Dedicated to midgetvilles (actual, photographed and documented ones - not the urban legend ones you looked for but could never find), mythical creatures, roadside wavers, egg-o-mats, hauntings, underground tunnels, and old-man bars. On their 18th printed issue, they don't seem to be running out of any weird stuff to report on.